Wander Inn
6 guests
2 bedrooms
Southold, The Hamptons
Wander Inn is an architect-renovated ranch in a beautiful setting. Built in the sixties, this home is made for relaxation and indulgence.
Shelter Island Unique Homes
We selected the 936 homes worth renting in this location
Home spotlights in Shelter Island
The Edge
6 guests
3 bedrooms
Ulster County, Rochester
This NYT-featured Catskills home is not quite the cabin it seems to be. What looks like a single storey home from one angle is actually built over a creekside slope, and we think it's one of the most interesting places we've seen for a peaceful stay in the woods.
When In Bloom
6 guests
3 bedrooms
Southampton, The Hamptons
This Hamptons house sits on seven acres of lush greenery, with plenty of space for both kids and adults to enjoy. Old meets new inside, with patterned rugs, antique furniture and an imposing fireplace, along with a slick kitchen complete with coffee grinder and juicer.
We selected the top 3% holiday homes in Shelter Island Unique Homes
Explore the 936 most perfect homes in our collection
View on map
Check upcoming rates & availability for Shelter Island Unique Homes
Frequently asked questions
Similar destinations
Plum guide offers a handpicked selection of the most unique homes in Shelter Island. Our homes come fully furnished with the best-equipped kitchens, essential bathroom toiletries and all linen included. Book a short or extended stay and secure the most unique home in Shelter Island for your next getaway. Our friendly team of Plum Experts are on-hand 24/7 should you need anything.
Search Our Collection